Decatur teacher challenges state law again - WAFF-TV: News, Weather and Sports for Huntsville, AL

Decatur teacher challenges state law again

Carrie Cabri Witt (Source: Decatur Police Department) Carrie Cabri Witt (Source: Decatur Police Department)
DECATUR, AL (WAFF) -

An indicted Decatur teacher is again challenging Alabama’s law on school employees engaging in sex acts with students.

Court documents shows Carrie Witt says the law under which she is charged is unconstitutional.

Witt’s attorney is now fighting the law in circuit court following her indictment after the first challenge to the law after her arrest was rejected in district challenge.

Witt was arrested in the spring on charges she had sex with two 17-year-old male students.

READ MORE: Decatur teacher charged with sex acts with students denies allegations

The court filing shows Witt claims she is being prosecuted for a romantic relationship with a consenting young man solely because of her employment with Decatur High School, which violates her 14th Amendment substantive due process privacy rights and equal protection rights.

Witt’s defense attorney Robert Tuten said in April that they are willing to take their challenge of the state law all the way to the Alabama Supreme Court if necessary.

"The statute forgets there's another body of law, another statute, that sets the age of consent of 16. It also goes against the grain of some U.S Supreme Court decisions that basically say that we cannot regulate and cannot legislate morality," Tuten said. "We're not arguing the ethics of it. We're not arguing the administrative procedures with a teacher where this happens. This is strictly a legal argument based on the facts as they were submitted in the allegations in the arrest warrant by the state."

READ MORE: Grand jury to hear case against teacher accused of sexual relationships with students

Tuten said the challenge is not a concession that his client had sex with students, rather a challenge to the existence of the law that allows the charge.

A separate court filing shows Witt is asking the circuit court to suppress all of Witt’s written and oral statements, alleging they were obtained in violation of her privilege against self-incrimination and her right to counsel. 

Copyright 2016 WAFF. All rights reserved.

Report an Error | Submit a Tip to WAFF 48

  • NewsMore>>

  • David: Showers and storms ongoing across the Valley

    David: Showers and storms ongoing across the Valley

    Saturday, March 25 2017 5:50 PM EDT2017-03-25 21:50:37 GMT

    Showers and storms will be ongoing across the Valley this evening. The most widespread rain will be over northeastern AL, but additional scattered storms will track into the Shoals from the west. That round of stormy weather will head east with time and should be out of the Valley after midnight. The threat for severe storms is low, but a few strong storms are possible. 

    More >>

    Showers and storms will be ongoing across the Valley this evening. The most widespread rain will be over northeastern AL, but additional scattered storms will track into the Shoals from the west. That round of stormy weather will head east with time and should be out of the Valley after midnight. The threat for severe storms is low, but a few strong storms are possible. 

    More >>
  • Amber Alert for 11-month-old Pickens County boy

    Amber Alert for 11-month-old Pickens County boy

    Saturday, March 25 2017 5:35 PM EDT2017-03-25 21:35:14 GMT

    The State of Alabama has issued an Amber Alert for a missing 11-month-old boy last seen the city of Gordo on March 25.

    The Alabama Police Department and Alabama Law Enforcement Agency is asking the public to help locate Christian Clay Perkins.

    More >>

    The State of Alabama has issued an Amber Alert for a missing 11-month-old boy last seen the city of Gordo on March 25.

    The Alabama Police Department and Alabama Law Enforcement Agency is asking the public to help locate Christian Clay Perkins.

    More >>
  • New details released in Guntersville double shooting

    New details released in Guntersville double shooting

    Saturday, March 25 2017 2:07 PM EDT2017-03-25 18:07:30 GMT
    Guntersville police say two people were shot at this mobile home area on Edmonds Road. (Source: WAFF)Guntersville police say two people were shot at this mobile home area on Edmonds Road. (Source: WAFF)

    The Guntersville Police Department have released news details on a double shooting late Friday afternoon that left one man dead.

    The incident occurred at approximately 5:30 p.m., when police from multiple law enforcement agencies responded to a 911 call reporting two people had been shot on Edmonds Road.

    More >>

    The Guntersville Police Department have released news details on a double shooting late Friday afternoon that left one man dead.

    The incident occurred at approximately 5:30 p.m., when police from multiple law enforcement agencies responded to a 911 call reporting two people had been shot on Edmonds Road.

    More >>
Powered by Frankly