Questions about federal judge's arrest remain unanswered - WAFF-TV: News, Weather and Sports for Huntsville, AL

Questions about federal judge's arrest remain unanswered

U.S. District Judge Patricia Minaldi. (Source: KPLC) U.S. District Judge Patricia Minaldi. (Source: KPLC)
LAKE CHARLES, LA (KPLC) -

More than two weeks after being stopped by city police, a Lake Charles federal judge paid a fine for an open-container summons.

But the investigation into the matter isn't over.

U.S. District Judge Patricia Minaldi was pulled over Jan. 23 after a 911 caller reported an erratic driver.

Lake Charles City Attorney Billy Loftin claims that while the case has received a lot of attention, the incident was routine.

The 911 call tells a different story. You can read the 911 dispatch records HERE and the Lake Charles Police dispatch records HERE.

The two-minute call, placed at 1:25 p.m., paints a picture of a driver who appears to be drunk.

Documents obtained by KPLC reveal the driver was Minaldi. Records also show four Lake Charles Police Department officers responded to the call, and witnesses say at least one followed Minaldi for less than a mile before she was stopped in her driveway on Fairway Drive.

Minaldi was taken into custody and transported to police headquarters. She was issued an open-container citation.

Citing a pending investigation, Lake Charles police have denied requests by KPLC for the video from the patrol vehicles' dash cameras and well as recordings of radio communications.

"That open-container violation may or may not be dispositive of all of the issues in this case," Loftin said. "So the simple explanation of the status is that there is an open file, an investigatory file, with the city police department relative to this incident."

Loftin said he trusts the police did the right thing.

"Police officers have a large amount of discretion as it relates to issuing citations. It happens every day up and down every street," he said. "I trust that they did their job."

The questions KPLC still wants answered are:

• Why was an open-container citation issued?

• Why is the incident still under investigation?

• Finally and most importantly, was Minaldi given a field-sobriety test? If not, why?

Lake Charles Police have repeatedly referred us to the news release on the incident which can be viewed HERE.

When asked about the details of the arrest and what witnesses claim they saw, Loftin said: "I'm not being evasive. I just don't have a comment on it. I haven't read it. I don't have any knowledge as to whether those accusations or allegations are true or not, and so I'm not in a proper position to comment."

Minaldi had even less to say on the matter.

When contacted by KPLC, she declined comment, telling us she's "paid the ticket and it's over."

As for the open investigation, Loftin did not have a timeline on when it is expected to be completed.

Copyright KPLC 2014. All rights reserved.

  • NewsMore>>

  • Amber Alert canceled for Pickens County boy

    Amber Alert canceled for Pickens County boy

    Saturday, March 25 2017 6:31 PM EDT2017-03-25 22:31:56 GMT

    Alabama Law Enforcement Agency has CANCELLED the Amber Alert for 11-month-old Christian Clay Perkins. 

    More >>

    Alabama Law Enforcement Agency has CANCELLED the Amber Alert for 11-month-old Christian Clay Perkins. 

    More >>
  • David: Showers and storms ongoing across the Valley

    David: Showers and storms ongoing across the Valley

    Saturday, March 25 2017 5:50 PM EDT2017-03-25 21:50:37 GMT

    Showers and storms will be ongoing across the Valley this evening. The most widespread rain will be over northeastern AL, but additional scattered storms will track into the Shoals from the west. That round of stormy weather will head east with time and should be out of the Valley after midnight. The threat for severe storms is low, but a few strong storms are possible. 

    More >>

    Showers and storms will be ongoing across the Valley this evening. The most widespread rain will be over northeastern AL, but additional scattered storms will track into the Shoals from the west. That round of stormy weather will head east with time and should be out of the Valley after midnight. The threat for severe storms is low, but a few strong storms are possible. 

    More >>
  • New details released in Guntersville double shooting

    New details released in Guntersville double shooting

    Saturday, March 25 2017 2:07 PM EDT2017-03-25 18:07:30 GMT
    Guntersville police say two people were shot at this mobile home area on Edmonds Road. (Source: WAFF)Guntersville police say two people were shot at this mobile home area on Edmonds Road. (Source: WAFF)

    The Guntersville Police Department have released news details on a double shooting late Friday afternoon that left one man dead.

    The incident occurred at approximately 5:30 p.m., when police from multiple law enforcement agencies responded to a 911 call reporting two people had been shot on Edmonds Road.

    More >>

    The Guntersville Police Department have released news details on a double shooting late Friday afternoon that left one man dead.

    The incident occurred at approximately 5:30 p.m., when police from multiple law enforcement agencies responded to a 911 call reporting two people had been shot on Edmonds Road.

    More >>
Powered by Frankly